From potential Oscar-winning films to undeniable disappointments, 2024 delivered some unforgettable cinematic moments – a mix of films we’ll eagerly rewatch and others we’d rather forget. Here’s a look back at the films that defined our year.
Let’s start where we agree: “Wicked” was pure magic! With heartfelt characters and an enchanting soundtrack we’ll be humming long until part two is released, it’s no surprise this musical adaptation made both our top lists.
In my opinion (Francine), “Challengers” and “The Substance” were among the best films of the year. “Challengers” had captivating storytelling, the angstiest soundtrack and remarkable lead performances from Zendaya, Mike Faist and Josh O’Connor. Director Luca Guadagnino captured the drama on and off the tennis court of a 13-year-long love triangle between main characters Tashi, Art and Patrick.
Recently, “The Substance” became a favorite. Demi Moore stars as a fading celebrity who takes a black-market drug to create a younger version of herself. Campy, gory and a real nail-biter, the film offered commentary on the societal pressures of women aging.
For me (Hayley), the best films were the ones that made me cry. “We Live in Time” delivered incredibly raw, realistic storytelling, making viewers deeply invested in the couple’s journey. “My Old Ass,” starring Aubrey Plaza, also stood out, offering a fresh take on the coming-of-age genre that will resonate with generations to come.
However, not every movie hit the mark. “Madame Web” felt like another unnecessary superhero movie, and while “Speak No Evil” was an improvement from the original, it was far from memorable.
Hayley here – I think it’s fair to say the horror really fell flat in 2024. “Tarot” was one of the most laughable films, relying heavily on stereotypical tropes, the rise in tarot culture online and excessive gore. It failed to be even remotely fear-inducing.
Another group of flops for us was all the sequels! “Smile 2” was a poorly written horror flick that failed to live up to its predecessor. Meanwhile, “Beetlejuice Beetlejuice” did tickle everyone’s nostalgia bone, but it didn’t live up to the buildup we all had hoped for in returning to the whimsical world of The Afterlife. The practical effects recaptured some viewers right back to the original’s charm, but the storyline itself felt messy, as if too many plots were crammed together.
Overall, 2024 was a strange year for film, with a few diamonds among a lot of rough. Most would agree this was not the year for horror, remakes and sequels. But if you were into romance, tear-jerkers or the type of films that have you leaving the theater on the cusp of an existential crisis, then this was the year for you.
Looking ahead to 2025, we’re excited for “Companion,” “Mickey 17,” “Frankenstein,” “How to Train Your Dragon” and of course “Wicked: Part Two.” Stay tuned for the next review!